Prostitution Is Revolution
Jan. 31st, 2008 12:24 pmI've been thinking about porn a lot this morning.
Or, well, smutty fan fic. And the stirring across various fandoms that smut is on the decline, ever since the whole LJ strikethrough debacle. Now, maybe it is in some fandoms, but I haven't seen too much evidence of it in my fandoms.
Death Note is still saturated daily with Light/L pr0n. Plenty of FMA pr0n pops up on my Flist. Ouran pr0n as well. And I'd say there's still just as much pr0n in HBC fandom, but as I'm the only one writing it, it's not exactly a good gauge. But I have noticed a change in the pr0n.
Anyway, all this just led me to wondering what's going on with the whole thing. The people who instituted the policy (whatever said policy is) are gone. I haven't heard anything about anyone being banned or booted or even warned over fic in which the participants are shy of 18. Hell, I used all my other journals to flag one of my old fics - Envy/Winry, non-con, Winry is 14 and yes, this is mentioned a few times in the fic and in the warnings - and nothing happened.
So I wonder: is that dark cloud passed? Do we still need to fear for our teenage smut? Is everyone who's carefully avoiding writing anything with anyone under 18 being paranoid, or safe?
I never changed my fic writing through the whole thing - I'll argue the artistic merit of my pr0n until the cows come home - but I know plenty of people who did. And I understand their reasons. But I can't help but wonder if it was just one spike in the waves of fandom.
The main reason I'm wondering is because I like to read smut that involves a handful of teenage characters. I miss the fact that there used to be at least one Kyouya/Tamaki fic on my Flist on any given day. Now...not so much. Or they're aged up, which doesn't appeal to me. And there has been a dramatic decline in Ed/Al ficcage. Now I don't know if this is because FMA has passed its peak or not, but since it started when this whole thing went down, I'm going to guess they're linked.
(I'd like to note here I'm talking specifically about LJ, not archives or other journaling services.)
Anyway, I miss my pr0n.And I hate that I have to end up being OOC with one of my characters because according to former LJ overlords, 18 is some magical number all over the world and all fan fic is child porn.
SO! Discuss. Are we being paranoid? Are we being smart? Has Strikethrough really effected fandom? Or just LJ fandom? How much of LJ fandom is fandom?
These are all the questions that ran through my mind this morning, as I lay in bed trying to recover from another one of those dreams. Om nom nom.
Or, well, smutty fan fic. And the stirring across various fandoms that smut is on the decline, ever since the whole LJ strikethrough debacle. Now, maybe it is in some fandoms, but I haven't seen too much evidence of it in my fandoms.
Death Note is still saturated daily with Light/L pr0n. Plenty of FMA pr0n pops up on my Flist. Ouran pr0n as well. And I'd say there's still just as much pr0n in HBC fandom, but as I'm the only one writing it, it's not exactly a good gauge. But I have noticed a change in the pr0n.
Anyway, all this just led me to wondering what's going on with the whole thing. The people who instituted the policy (whatever said policy is) are gone. I haven't heard anything about anyone being banned or booted or even warned over fic in which the participants are shy of 18. Hell, I used all my other journals to flag one of my old fics - Envy/Winry, non-con, Winry is 14 and yes, this is mentioned a few times in the fic and in the warnings - and nothing happened.
So I wonder: is that dark cloud passed? Do we still need to fear for our teenage smut? Is everyone who's carefully avoiding writing anything with anyone under 18 being paranoid, or safe?
I never changed my fic writing through the whole thing - I'll argue the artistic merit of my pr0n until the cows come home - but I know plenty of people who did. And I understand their reasons. But I can't help but wonder if it was just one spike in the waves of fandom.
The main reason I'm wondering is because I like to read smut that involves a handful of teenage characters. I miss the fact that there used to be at least one Kyouya/Tamaki fic on my Flist on any given day. Now...not so much. Or they're aged up, which doesn't appeal to me. And there has been a dramatic decline in Ed/Al ficcage. Now I don't know if this is because FMA has passed its peak or not, but since it started when this whole thing went down, I'm going to guess they're linked.
(I'd like to note here I'm talking specifically about LJ, not archives or other journaling services.)
Anyway, I miss my pr0n.
SO! Discuss. Are we being paranoid? Are we being smart? Has Strikethrough really effected fandom? Or just LJ fandom? How much of LJ fandom is fandom?
These are all the questions that ran through my mind this morning, as I lay in bed trying to recover from another one of those dreams. Om nom nom.